Development of Hypertension in a Cohort of Cuban Adolescents

INTRODUCTION
Primary hypertension has its origins in childhood and is a risk factor for atherosclerosis; it is considered an important health problem because of its high prevalence worldwide.


OBJECTIVE
Describe the development of hypertension during adolescence, including some factors that influence its persistence and progression in Cuban adolescents.


METHODS
A cohort study was conducted in an intentional sample of 252 apparently healthy adolescents from the catchment area of the Héroes del Moncada Polyclinic in Plaza de la Revolución Municipality, Havana. They were assessed in two cross-sectional studies in 2004 and 2008. Mean age at first assessment was 13.2 years, 17.1 years at the second. Variables were weight, height, body mass index, waist circumference, blood pressure, smoking, family history of hypertension and birth weight. Correlation coefficients and growth curve analyses were applied to assess blood pressure persistence. Risk of developing prehypertension and hypertension was estimated in the second assessment, based on predictors identified in the 2004 cut. Forecasting models with these factors were developed using classification trees as analytical tools.


RESULTS
Of the six adolescents categorized as hypertensive in the first assessment, five still showed blood pressure alterations after four years. The main factors related to hypertension in those aged 16-19 were blood pressure itself and a body mass index >90th percentile, followed by low birth weight and abdominal obesity. Prognostic models for predicting this condition at the end of adolescence demonstrated the importance of blood pressure alterations at age 12-15 years.


CONCLUSIONS
High rates of persistence and progression of hypertension during adolescence highlights the need for systematic blood pressure screening at the primary health care level and adoption of primary prevention strategies beginning in childhood.


INTRODUCTION
Atherosclerosis and related diseases are leading causes of death in countries where infections are not predominant.[1] Research focused on identifying atherogenic risk factors in children and adolescents shows that signifi cant atherosclerosis precursors in adults are established early in life.This is when patterns of unhealthy diet, physical inactivity and smoking are formed, diffi cult to change later.[2,3] Progression and severity of cardiovascular diseases are related to these risk factors and their persistence over time.Furthermore, longitudinal studies in pediatric populations show the tendency of cardiovascular risk factors to persist.[4] Such studies enable identifi cation of persons at risk for cardiovascular diseases based on measurements made early in life.These risk factors may be useful as early screening targets, while care should be taken to correct abnormal values.[5] Predisposition to atherosclerosis may already exist in childhood, induced by biological factors-both hereditary and nonhereditary-and environmental factors.All of the following in childhood are associated with coronary artery calcifi cation and early cardiovascular disease: obesity, physical inactivity, hypertension (HT), high serum cholesterol, smoking and diabetes.[6] Study of early signs of atherogenesis has been one of the main objectives of the Havana Atherosclerosis Research and Reference Center (CIRAH) since its creation.Between 1986 and 1996, WHO conducted a multinational research project entitled Pathobiological Determinants of Atherosclerosis in Youth, [6] and Cuba was one of 18 countries involved.Participation in this project led to a number of epidemiological studies demonstrating signs of early atherogenesis (most frequently overweight and HT) in children and adolescents.[7,8] Hypertension is a major cardiovascular risk factor and is increasing worldwide, provoking extremely important health, social and economic problems.Reported prevalence in Cuban adults is about 30%.[9] Global prevalence in children is not known precisely.[10,11] However, several studies have reported a high frequency of HT and pre-HT in Cuban children and adolescents.Fernández-Britto found 4.7% primary HT and 9.7% pre-HT in a sample of 1026 secondary school (grades 7 to 9) students of both sexes in Havana.[12] Álvarez reported similar fi ndings in Havana, [13] while Suárez identifi ed 9.3% of adolescents as hypertensive in Santiago de Cuba Municipality.[14] Despite these fi ndings, the subject remains to be fully addressed in pediatrics.
Longitudinal studies in children and adolescents demonstrate that high blood pressure persists over time and can predict adult HT. [4,5] Clinical perspectives on blood pressure in children have changed in recent years as a result of improved knowledge of normal values and systematic blood pressure measurement in well child visits.Thus, the importance of including regular blood pressure measurement in clinical practice is now widely recognized, both for early detection of asymptomatic HT in children and adolescents, and because HT early in life constitutes a risk marker for this condition in adulthood.[14] In 2009, the European Society of Hypertension declared HT in children a major and growing health problem requiring organized strategies to address it.[15] Despite evidence showing the relationship between childhood and adult HT, research conclusions are inconsistent.Explanations of these inconsistencies include differences in cutoff points used, age groups selected, different followup times, and different methods for tracking blood pressure.[16] Longitudinal studies describing evolution of atherogenic risk factors in children and adolescents are rare in Cuba.The purpose of our research was to describe blood pressure evolution and factors influencing HT persistence and progression in a cohort of Havana adolescents.Study outcomes will expand

Original Research
our knowledge on the subject and provide essential inputs for designing effective interventions at the primary health care level.

METHODS
A longitudinal study was conducted with two cross-sectional cuts, the fi rst in 2004 and the second in 2008.The universe comprised 323 adolescents aged 12-15 years from the catchment area of Héroes del Moncada Polyclinic in Plaza de la Revolución Municipality, Havana, assessed in January-December 2004.Of these, 252 completed the second assessment in December 2008, constituting the study population (22% loss to followup).

Exclusion criteria
Residence outside the polyclinic catchment area or absence at the time of the study; obesity or secondary HT; pregnancy or recent childbirth.
Variables These are described in Table 1.
Procedures Before the study began, researchers visited each site-the family-doctor-and-nurse offi ce corresponding to each participant-to ensure that measurement conditions were satisfactory.In addition, one of the authors was present at each session to monitor compliance with accuracy standards.Each child was interviewed and examined in the presence of his/her family in order to avoid omission bias regarding family history and birth weight.Data were collected using CIRAH's primary data collection form.
Anthropometric measurements including weight, height and waist circumference were performed in both assessments.For body mass index, the Quetelet index [weight in kg/(height in m) 2 ] was used.Equipment was calibrated and monitored in accordance with International Biological Program standards.[21] Research team members at each site received training on study procedures, and measurements were taken by the same research team on both study dates.Initial anthropometric measurements taken at each assessment were replicated twice, for a total of three measurements on the same day, and the average was calculated.As a data quality control procedure, fi ve adolescents were randomly selected and all measurements were repeated.This process included calculation of technical measurement error and reliability index.
Systolic and diastolic blood pressure were taken after subjects had rested for fi ve minutes, each sitting upright with the right arm positioned at heart level, [19] and without having smoked or taken medication that day.An aneroid blood pressure cuff and calibrated stethoscope (SMIC, China) were used.Repeated measurements were taken at fi ve-minute intervals.
Statistical analysis Data were processed with SPSS for Windows, version 18.0.Persistence was analyzed by building dual-entry tables to relate blood pressure classifi cation on initial assessment with that of fi nal assessment.Odds ratios and 95% confi dence intervals were calculated for blood pressure alteration at age 16-19 years.Classifi cation trees were used as prognostic models for pre-HT and HT at fi nal assessment, based on factors identifi ed initially.The classifi cation trees allowed us to identify which independent variables were most important as predictors of blood pressure alterations at age 16-19 years.They are also a practical, easily interpreted method for determining HT persistence and establishing optimal cutoff points for the sample.The chi-square automatic interaction detection method was used.[22] The classifi cation trees were constructed with ordinal variables, and also with continuous variables in order to fi nd optimal cutoff points according to their original measurements.Two variants were used for continuous variables: as continuous variables and as categorical synthetic variables.In practice, the latter may be a preferred option because it provides simpler prediction algorithms, while the former is more informative analytically, since it further proposes optimal cutoff points and allows for inclusion of possible nonlinear relationships among predictors and risk, thereby producing more sensitive forecasts.

Ethical considerations
The study was reviewed and approved by the CIRAH ethics committee.Written informed consent was obtained from the participants and their parents or guardians.

RESULTS
Mean participant age was 13.2 years at the fi rst assessment, and 17.1 years at the second.Sex composition was balanced.

Original Research
HT was detected in six teenagers in the initial assessment, of whom only one moved to a lower percentile after four years.Of the 18 prehypertensive teens, 8 (44.4%) persisted as such, and 3 (16.7%)progressed to HT (Table 2).The OR for HT in the second measurement was 4.9 for adolescents with blood pressure >90th percentile at age 12-15 years.Next, in order of importance, came BMI >90th percentile (OR 3.6), low birth weight, and waist circumference >90th percentile (Figure 1).
At each step, the chi-square automatic interaction detection classifi cation tree effected different partitions, choosing from among all independent variables entered into the model the one showing the strongest interaction with the dependent variable.Blood pressure classifi cation in the initial assessment at the beginning of the study, nutritional assessment classifi cation, waist circumference, and family history of HT and smoking were introduced into the model.Blood pressure classifi cation at the beginning of the study was selected by the model as the most important variable for predicting being prehypertensive or hypertensive at the second assessment.Figure 2 shows the classifi cation tree with blood pressure as a categorical variable.Teens who initially had altered blood pressure had a 66.7% risk of being hypertensive or prehypertensive by age 16-19.
By introducing as predictors the independent variables SBP, DBP, waist circumference and BMI treated as continuous, the model made two partitions, selecting fi rst SBP and then BMI.
When stratifi ed by sex, different effects of continuous variables were observed for male and female subjects.The most important variable for male subjects was SBP, followed by BMI.When SBP values at age 12-15 were >110 mmHg, the probability of becoming hypertensive or prehypertensive in 4 years' time was 68%.For female subjects, however, the tree structure changed completely, especially in the terminal nodes, showing waist circumference as the main variable, followed by DBP, with a risk of 24% if waist circumference was >68 cm, increasing to 36.7% if DBP >60 mmHg was also present at the beginning of the study (Figure 4).

DISCUSSION
Adolescence is a complex stage of human development because the growth that has occurred continuously from conception is combined with signs of maturity apparent with the onset of puberty.During this stage, behavioral patterns are established and some risk factors come to light that infl uence health at the beginning of adulthood.
Blood pressure values in childhood tend to remain on the same growth curve over time, which means that children in higher blood pressure percentiles will remain in that range into adulthood.This tracking pattern starts early on, which supports the hypothesis that primary HT begins in childhood.[23] Although information regarding progression from pre-HT to HT among adolescents is limited, the persistence of HT observed in this study is in line with research suggesting that children and adolescents with blood pressure at the high end of the distribution tend to have HT as young adults.[5,16,23] Data from a US study to determine the consequences of HT in adolescence suggest that progression from pre-HT to HT (based on a single measurement) is approximately 7% per year, and that pre-HT carries a high risk of progression to HT in adolescence.
[10] It is estimated that individuals with DBP near 90 mmHg when aged 15 years are twice as likely to have DBP >90 mmHg at age 35 years as those with lower initial values.[24][25][26] Field reported a risk of developing altered blood pressure 5.1 times higher in children with BMI >85th percentile.[27] The classifi cation trees in our study confi rmed the persistence of HT through adolescence.Furthermore, results showed that BMI at age 12-15 years is associated with alterations in blood pressure later in adolescence.This relationship could be explained by three main pathophysiological mechanisms: impaired autonomic function, insulin resistance, and abnormalities in vascular structure and function.This link may be mediated by the sympathetic nervous system, with a hyperactive state that has been confi rmed in different studies involving obese children and adolescents.[28] Lower vascular compliance has been found in obese children, similar to that of children with diabetes and familial hypercholesterolemia. Endothelial dysfunction has also been suggested as a problem associated with obesity.Recent research links obesity, C-reactive protein and SBP, suggesting a possible pathophysiological mechanism: impaired vascular function caused by chronic infl ammation in obese children as a predictor for developing HT.[29,30] A cohort study of Brazilian children who were followed for 17 years to adulthood showed that sustained elevated blood pressure was associated with a more unfavorable cardiovascular risk profi le, with higher prevalence of HT, overweight/obesity, lipid and glucose abnormalities, and metabolic syndrome in adulthood, [31] confi rming the need for preventive measures beginning early in life.

Original Research
Sex differences found in the classifi cation trees highlight the behavior of this variable as an effect modifi er.It should be borne in mind that in the fi rst stage of the research, children were between early and middle adolescence, which coincides with a period of rapid growth.Increases in blood pressure with age are related to body size and can differ by sex, since puberty occurs at different ages for boys and girls.Puberty is a time of important anthropometric, hormonal and lipid changes associated with sexual maturation, which contribute to differences in cardiovascular risk factors between the sexes.[23,32,33] Evidence suggests that elevated blood pressure in childhood is a predictor for HT in adulthood and that some lifestyle-related risk factors, such as unhealthy diet and physical inactivity, remain stable from childhood on; hence prevention is more effective if lifestyles are changed early in life.[33] While some research conducted in Cuba shows early atherogenic signs in children and adolescents, few studies aim at understanding its progression.[1,7,8,[12][13][14] Pérez addressed the question of progression to HT in a longitudinal study involving prehypertensive children in the city of Santa Clara.He concluded that the interaction from adolescence to adulthood of such factors as age at onset of pre-HT, birth weight, family obesity and an unfavor-Peer Reviewed able family environment contributed to progression from pre-HT to HT. [34] This study describes the progression of HT in a cohort of adolescents.Within its scope, it was possible to identify early signs of atherogenesis in a group of adolescents who appeared healthy when first examined.This research demonstrates the need for appropriate blood pressure screening and management in order to avoid adverse health outcomes later in life.

CONCLUSIONS
The high persistence and the progression of HT in adolescence highlight the need for systematic screening at the primary health care level as well as adoption of primary prevention strategies from an early age.

Table 1 : Variables
BMI: body mass index DBP: diastolic blood pressure HT: hypertension SBP: systolic blood pressure Peer Reviewed

Table 2 : Relationship between initial and fi nal BP classifi cations
BP: blood pressure HT: hypertension Pre-HT: pre-hypertension Figure 1:

Prediction of BP at age 16-19 years by BP at age 12-15 years (CHAID classifi cation tree, categorical variable) Classifi cation of BP2 Category
BP1: blood pressure at age 12-15 years BP2: blood pressure at age 16-19 years CHAID: chi-square automatic interaction detection